A Gentle Start: Top 10 Butt Plugs for Beginners & Your Safe Anal Play Journey
This **best butt plugs for beginners review** is your safe, gentle, and comprehensive starting point for exploring the incredible world of anal pleasure. Curiosity about anal play is natural, but it’s often accompanied by questions and apprehension: Will it hurt? Is it safe? What do I even look for in a toy? It’s easy to feel overwhelmed, but your journey should be filled with excitement and discovery, not fear.
That’s why we’ve created this guide. We’ve meticulously tested and selected only the most **comfortable butt plugs** designed specifically for new users. We will not only review the top toys but also provide a detailed **anal training guide** that covers everything from **how to use a butt plug** safely to choosing the **best lube for anal**. Your exciting adventure starts now.
| Product | Rating | Price | |
|---|---|---|---|
|
1. b-Vibe Snug Plug 2: The Perfect First Plug
|
$49.99 | Check Price | |
|
2. Fun Factory Bootie: Best for Flexibility & Comfort
|
$29.99 | Check Price | |
|
3. LELO Kiri: Best Introduction to Vibration
|
$95.00 | Check Price | |
|
4. Doc Johnson Mood Naughty 1: The Best Value Training Plug
|
$14.99 | Check Price | |
|
5. Njoy Pure Plug Small: Best for Temperature Play
|
$59.00 | Check Price |
Our Non-Negotiable Criteria for Beginner Butt Plugs
Safety and comfort are paramount. A product only made it onto our **best butt plugs for beginners review** if it met these four essential criteria:
- Flared Safety Base: Absolutely non-negotiable. Every plug must have a base that is significantly wider than the neck to prevent it from going too far in. Safety first, always.
- Tapered Tip & Small Size: We selected plugs with a narrow, tapered tip for easy, gentle insertion. The overall sizes are small and unintimidating, perfect for getting comfortable with the sensation of fullness.
- Premium Body-Safe Materials: We prioritized silky-smooth, 100% body-safe silicone. This material is non-porous, easy to clean, and feels warm and comfortable against the body.
- Ergonomic Design: We looked for plugs with a thin, flexible neck that rests comfortably between the butt cheeks for potential long-term wear without discomfort.
The Ultimate Ranking of Beginner-Friendly Butt Plugs for 2025
1. b-Vibe Snug Plug 2: The Perfect First Plug
If you buy one plug to start your journey, this is it. The b-Vibe Snug Plug is engineered to perfection for beginners. It has a super tapered tip, a flexible neck, a secure base, and is made from seamless, buttery-soft silicone. It also contains a small weighted ball inside that provides a gentle, satisfying jiggle as you move. It is, without question, the gold standard.
2. Fun Factory Bootie: Best for Flexibility & Comfort
The Bootie is incredibly soft and flexible, making it one of the most **comfortable butt plugs** for new users. Made in Germany from 100% silicone, its shape is wonderfully ergonomic, and its extreme flexibility allows it to move with your body. It’s an exceptionally forgiving and welcoming choice for those who are nervous about insertion.
3. LELO Kiri: Best Introduction to Vibration
Curious about adding vibration to the mix? The LELO Kiri is the perfect tool. It’s shaped like a string of small beads and offers 6 powerful vibration patterns in a small, approachable size. The vibrations are deep and rumbly, introducing an entirely new layer of sensation to the feeling of fullness. It’s luxury, power, and beginner-friendliness all in one.
4. Doc Johnson Mood Naughty 1: The Best Value Training Plug
This plug proves you don’t need to spend a lot to start safely. Part of a progressive training kit, the “Naughty 1” is perfectly sized for absolute beginners. It’s made in the USA from body-safe, firm-yet-flexible silicone and has a super tapered tip. It’s the most affordable, high-quality option to see if anal play is for you. A key inclusion in any **best butt plugs for beginners review**.
5. Njoy Pure Plug Small: Best for Temperature Play
For a completely different experience, try metal. The Njoy Pure Plug is crafted from a single piece of body-safe stainless steel. It has a satisfying weight and is amazing for temperature play—warm it up in hot water or chill it for a thrilling sensation. The small size is perfect for beginners, and because it’s non-porous, it’s the easiest plug to clean and will literally last forever.
The Most Important Rule: Why Lube is Your Best Friend
Unlike the vagina, the anus does not self-lubricate. This makes using a high-quality lubricant absolutely essential, not just for comfort, but for safety. The right lube prevents friction, which can cause discomfort and microscopic tears. When it comes to the **best lube for anal**, you have two great options:
- Water-Based Lube: The universal choice. It’s safe to use with all toy materials (especially silicone), easy to clean up, and affordable. The only downside is that it can dry out and may need to be reapplied. Sliquid H2O is a fantastic, body-safe option.
- Silicone-Based Lube: Incredibly long-lasting and super slick. It’s perfect for anal play *with non-silicone toys* (like glass or steel) or without toys. **Warning:** Never use silicone lube with silicone toys as it will cause a chemical reaction and ruin your toy.
For a detailed guide on choosing the right product, authoritative sources like Healthline offer excellent advice on the topic.
How to Use a Butt Plug Safely and Comfortably
Your Step-by-Step Anal Training Guide
Total Time Needed: PT15M
Step 1: Relax, Relax, Relax
Your body’s natural reaction to nervousness is to tense up, which is the enemy of comfortable insertion. Take a warm bath, practice deep breathing, or engage in other forms of foreplay first. A relaxed body and mind are crucial.
Step 2: Apply a Generous Amount of Lube
Don’t be shy! Apply a generous amount of water-based lubricant to the plug, especially the tip, and also to the entrance of your anus. There is no such thing as too much lube when you’re starting out.
Step 3: Gentle Insertion
Get into a comfortable position (lying on your side with knees bent is great for beginners). Align the tapered tip of the plug and gently press. As you exhale slowly, push the plug in. The key is to go slow and listen to your body. If you feel any sharp pain, stop, add more lube, and relax before trying again.
Step 4: Wear and Enjoy (and Safe Removal)
Once the plug is past the sphincter and the flared base is resting securely outside, you’ve done it! Start by wearing it for short periods (15-20 minutes) to get used to the sensation. When you’re ready to remove it, relax, bear down gently as if having a bowel movement, and pull slowly on the base. Easy!
Answering Your Top Beginner Questions
Will using a butt plug make me need to poop?
The sensation of fullness might initially feel similar, but your body quickly learns the difference. The plug sits in the anal canal, while feces are stored higher up in the rectum. To ease your mind, simply use the restroom before you play.
Will a butt plug stretch me out permanently?
No. This is a common myth. The anus is an incredibly elastic muscle designed to expand and contract. Once the plug is removed, it will return to its normal size. This is why our **best butt plugs for beginners review** focuses on smaller sizes for comfortable, temporary pleasure.
How long can I safely wear a butt plug?
When starting, stick to short periods of 20-30 minutes. As you get more comfortable, you can wear them for longer. For multi-hour wear, choose a plug made from super-soft silicone with a very thin, comfortable neck, like the b-Vibe Snug Plug.